20 Great Unique Date Ideas in New York City

This blog post is all about date ideas in New York.

Dating in New York is a sport in itself. But a fun one nonetheless.

You only have to look at the numerous TV shows, movies and books about dating in New York City to know that this city hold something special romance-wise.

For me, New York is where my relationship started and I spent 10 months dating in the city and coming up with new and fun date ideas in New York to keep things exciting.

Many of the below are date ideas in New York for day and nights that I’ve had myself, but with some additional ideas I need to try out too.

I’m sending my good luck to you with your dating life in New York and I hope you have as much fun dating in this amazing city as I had.

RELATED Date Ideas in New York blog posts to read:

If you’re planning a trip to New York City, make sure to check out my 140+ page travel guide eBook which you can download here to help you plan!

This blog post is all about date ideas in New York.

20 Unique Date Ideas in New York

Below is a list of non-typical and unique date ideas in New York which are great for any time of the year.

But especially with Valentine’s Day on the horizon!

1. Go to a Live Sporting Event

Going to a sporting event in New York is one of the best date ideas in New York, especially with the level of entertainment that comes with each game.

Whether it’s a basketball game, baseball, American football or ice hockey, you’re sure to be entertained whilst also getting to know the other person during the down time between plays.

Below is a guide to locally New York and New Jersey based sporting teams:

American Football: New York Giants and New York Jets.
Baseball: New York Yankees and New York Mets (both MLB), and for a fun night of baseball, check out Brooklyn Cyclones in Coney Island for their annual Seinfeld night.
Basketball: New York Knicks, Brooklyn Nets and New York Liberty (WMBA).
Ice Hockey: New York Rangers, New York Islanders and New Jersey Devils (based in Newark, so not too far from Manhattan).

Take a look for tickets for these games on Ticketmaster here.

2. See a Broadway Show

Seeing a Broadway show is an ideal date night choice, offering world-class entertainment in a romantic and culturally enriching atmosphere.

The wide variety of shows allows you to cater to your and your date’s interests, and it’s a memorable occasion that supports the arts. See ticket options for Broadway here!

You could also combine it with a romantic dinner, making for a well-rounded and special date night.

If you’re planning a Broadway night, something classic like a maxi dress works perfectly. Stylish enough for dinner but still comfortable for the show.

This one is my particular favourite of the date ideas in New York, having seen so many Broadway shows during my time there.

I also got my partner into Broadway too by taking him to see The Book of Mormon and Wicked. He was quickly hooked!

RELATED blog post to read: 7 Broadway Musicals You Need to See in New York

Going to a comedy night in New York is a fantastic option from this list of date ideas in New York for its ability to create a fun, relaxed atmosphere through shared laughter (if you’re lucky to have the same sense of humour – could be a little awkward if not).

With a diverse range of comedic styles, it allows you to choose humour that suits you and your date’s preferences.

It also serves as a great icebreaker, and is often an affordable and late-night option, making it a well-rounded and enjoyable date choice.

See what comedians are performing in New York at any time here.

4. Enjoy a Jazz Night at Cafe Wha

Attending a jazz night in New York City is an excellent choice for date ideas in New York as it combines the charm of live music with the city’s rich musical heritage.

Jazz creates a sophisticated and romantic atmosphere, making it an ideal backdrop for a memorable date.

It offers a unique cultural experience, and the city boasts numerous iconic jazz venues like Cafe Wha?, providing a wide range of jazz styles to suit different tastes.

You can see my experience at Cafe Wha? on MacDougal Street when I visited the spot for New Year’s Eve in my New York YouTube vlog below:

5. Have a Picnic in Central Park

Having a picnic in Central Park offers a tranquil escape from the city’s hustle and bustle while providing a picturesque and romantic setting.

You can enjoy each other’s company amidst lush greenery, scenic landscapes, and the iconic Central Park landmarks.

It’s a budget-friendly option that allows you to bring your favourite foods, creating a personalised and intimate dining experience.

The relaxed atmosphere encourages open conversation, fostering a deeper connection between you and your date.

Additionally, the park offers a variety of activities like strolling, rowing, or simply people-watching, making it a versatile and memorable date option that celebrates nature and togetherness in the heart of the city.

One of the more wholesome date ideas in New York.

6. Dumpling-Hop in Chinatown

Exploring different dumpling spots in Chinatown is a great idea for a date in New York, providing a unique foodie adventure.

It allows you to try a variety of delicious dumpling styles while being in the vibrant and chaotic atmosphere of Chinatown. This is probably my favourite date idea in New York as there are so many cheap spots to try, all very close to each other.

It’s also budget-friendly, offering a cost-effective way to enjoy a wide variety of dumplings. Additionally, you can combine the foodie exploring with a leisurely walk through Chinatown’s bustling streets and markets.

I also took a food tasting tour of Chinatown with Like A Local and loved it! You can use my code ‘ORLAGH10‘ for 10% discount on any of their New York tours.

RELATED blog post to read: My 7 Favourite Dumpling Spots in New York City

7. Make the Most of New York Restaurant Week

Dining out during Restaurant Week in New York is an excellent idea for a date because it allows you to experience the city’s top restaurants at a more affordable price.

You can enjoy a high-quality meal in some of the city’s finest restaurants, often offering prix-fixe menus with multiple courses.

It adds an element of sophistication to your date while maintaining a budget-friendly aspect, making it an accessible way to enjoy a fine dining experience in one of the world’s culinary capitals.

We did this ourselves during Restaurant Week and were able to have a budget-friendly three course meal at the famous Butter restaurant in Midtown. It was also a fun date for me as it’s a famous Gossip Girl location too!

A budget-friendly option from these date ideas in New York.

If you’re planning a trip to New York City, make sure to check out my 140+ page travel guide eBook which you can download here to help you plan!

8. Spend a Day at Coney Island

Heading to Coney Island for a date in New York is an exciting and unique choice.

It offers a fun-filled day at the beach, amusement park rides, and a lively boardwalk atmosphere, making it perfect for a playful and adventurous date.

You can enjoy classic attractions like the iconic Cyclone roller coaster and the historic Wonder Wheel, followed by relaxing on the sandy beach or trying out carnival games and enjoying traditional Coney Island snacks like hot dogs.

9. Visit a Museum or Two

Visiting a museum is an excellent example of date ideas in New York as it offers a blend of culture, art, and intellectual engagement.

Museums like the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA), and many others provide a backdrop for meaningful conversations and shared exploration.

The art and historical artefacts spark discussion, reflection, and the opportunity to learn more about each other’s interests.

It’s a versatile option, allowing you to choose a museum that aligns with your date’s preferences, whether it’s art, history, science, or any other field.

My personal favourite museum? The Tenement Museum in the Lower East Side. It’s a lesser-known museum, but you learn a lot about the history of New York, immigration and how it’s one of the most diverse cities in the world.

RELATED blog post to read: The Best & Coolest Museums in New York to Visit

10. Take in the View and Sunset from a Rooftop Bar

Visiting a rooftop bar in New York City is one of the best date ideas in New York for its blend of ambiance and stunning skyline views.

It provides a chic and intimate setting where you can enjoy cocktails or a glass of wine while taking in breathtaking panoramic views of the city.

The elevated atmosphere, often with cozy seating and soft lighting, creates a sophisticated and romantic ambiance, making it perfect for a memorable date night.

It encourages relaxed conversation and allows you to enjoy the city’s iconic skyline, offering a unique perspective on the metropolis that can be a captivating backdrop for your date.

RELATED blog post to read: Five of the Best Rooftop Bars in New York

Empire State Building 230 5th rooftop bar

11. Spend a Day at Governor’s Island

Exploring Governor’s Island is a wonderful unique example of date ideas in New York due to its serene and scenic ambiance.

It offers a refreshing escape from the city’s hustle and bustle, with lush green spaces, historical sites, and stunning views of the Manhattan skyline.

You can take a leisurely bike ride or walk through the island, visit art installations, enjoy a picnic, or take part in various recreational activities like mini-golf or hammock lounging.

This peaceful, yet vibrant setting provides a charming backdrop for quality time together.

12. Show Off Your Ice Skating Skills

Ice skating in New York City one of the more romantic date ideas in New York, particularly during the winter season.

The city’s iconic ice skating rinks like Rockefeller Center and the Woolman Rink in Central Park provide a picturesque and festive atmosphere, with the city’s dazzling holiday lights as a backdrop.

It’s an active and enjoyable way to spend quality time together, and can make for a funny time if neither of you are very good.

Ice skating is suitable for all skill levels, making it accessible and fun for couples of various backgrounds. The charming setting and the opportunity to warm up with hot cocoa or a meal afterward make it a quintessential and memorable winter date in the heart of the city.

RELATED blog post to read: How to Spend Christmas Day in New York City

13. Browse a New York Christmas Market

Visiting a Christmas market in New York is one of the cutest date ideas in New York, especially during the holiday season.

These markets, such as the one in Union Square or Bryant Park, offer a magical, festive ambiance with twinkling lights, holiday decorations, and the scent of seasonal treats in the air.

You can stroll hand in hand, browse unique handmade gifts and crafts, and indulge in delicious holiday treats like hot chocolate and gingerbread cookies.

It’s a heartwarming experience, making it a perfect choice for a special, holiday-themed date night in the heart of the city.

RELATED blog post to read: The 9 Best Christmas Markets in New York City to Visit

14. Compete at Chelsea Piers

Exploring Chelsea Piers is another great one of the date ideas in New York because it offers a mix of recreational activities and beautiful waterfront views.

The location provides opportunities for activities like ice skating, rock climbing, golf, and bowling, making it a versatile choice for active or adventurous couples.

The scenic backdrop of the Hudson River and the city skyline adds a romantic touch, and you can easily combine your visit with a meal or a leisurely walk along the Hudson River Park.

Chelsea Piers offers a blend of fun and relaxation, making it an engaging and picturesque date option in the city.

If you’re planning a trip to New York City, make sure to check out my 140+ page travel guide eBook which you can download here to help you plan!

15. Stroll Around the Bronx Botanical Gardens

Visiting the Bronx Botanical Gardens is an excellent example of outdoor date ideas in New York. For its enchanting blend of natural beauty, an escape from the concrete jungle.

It provides a serene and picturesque setting for a peaceful and romantic date. Strolling hand in hand through the gardens, including the stunning Enid A. Haupt Conservatory. The variety of plant collections and seasonal exhibitions offers diverse experiences throughout the year.

The gardens also host events, workshops, and exhibitions. So make sure to check the calendar for something that may make your visit even more special.

Overall, the Bronx Botanical Gardens offer a charming, educational, and tranquil atmosphere, making it an ideal date location in the heart of New York.

Just check if your date has any pollen allergies or hayfever before you go.

16. Kayak Along the Hudson River

Kayaking on the Hudson River is one of the perfect summer date ideas in New York. It combines adventure with breathtaking waterfront views.

It offers a unique and active experience that can strengthen the connection between you and your date. Paddling along the river while taking in the city’s iconic skyline is both exhilarating and serene. Providing a memorable backdrop for your date.

Additionally, many kayaking facilities offer this activity for free or at a low cost. Making it an accessible and budget-friendly option for an enjoyable and refreshing date.

One of the more adventurous date ideas in New York.

17. Eat Your Way Around Arthur Avenue, the Real Little Italy

Exploring Arthur Avenue in the Bronx is one of the most excellent date ideas in New York, due to its authentic and rich Italian culture.

Often referred to as the “real Little Italy,” Arthur Avenue offers a delightful and unique culinary and cultural experience.

You can visit traditional Italian bakeries, markets, and family-owned restaurants. Savouring authentic Italian cuisine like fresh pasta, cannoli, and artisanal cheeses.

The ambiance is welcoming and charming, creating a relaxed atmosphere for a meaningful date.

The opportunity to stroll through the vibrant neighbourhood and enjoy the rich flavours, aromas, and heritage of Italian cuisine makes Arthur Avenue a memorable and culturally enriching date choice in the heart of the Bronx.

Not the most ideal date ideas in New York if your date is lactose or gluten intolerant.

RELATED Date Ideas in New York blog post to read: 30 of the Best Cheap Eats in New York City for Under $10

18. Row Across Central Park Lake

Rowing on Central Park Lake is one of the most romantic date ideas in New York, offering a blend of outdoor adventure and romantic tranquility.

It allows you to take in the natural beauty of Central Park while working together in a shared physical activity (make sure your date does the heavy lifting while you take in the scenery), enhancing the connection between you and your date.

The serene setting, with the iconic Bow Bridge and cityscape as a backdrop, adds to the romantic atmosphere.

It’s a unique and leisurely way to enjoy the city’s green oasis while creating lasting memories on the water.

19. Take A Cooking Class Together

Taking a cooking class as a date offers a blend of learning, creativity, and shared experiences. It encourages collaboration as you work together to prepare a meal, fostering a sense of partnership and communication.

The hands-on nature of the class, like this unique bagel-making class, allows you to explore your culinary skills while under the guidance of an expert, making it an engaging and educational activity.

Plus, you get to enjoy the delicious fruits of your labor, creating a rewarding and memorable meal together.

Cooking classes are often available in a variety of cuisines and make for great date ideas in New York. Allowing you to tailor the experience to your and your date’s tastes. And they provide a fun and interactive way to connect and create a lasting shared memory.

20. Enjoy A Sunset Cruise Along the Hudson River

Taking a sunset cruise is one of the most popular date ideas in New York as it combines romance, relaxation, and stunning views.

With the city’s iconic skyline as a backdrop, it’s easy to have a picturesque and romantic experience. Watching the sun set over the water is a breathtaking sight, creating a memorable and intimate atmosphere for your date.

It’s a leisurely way to unwind, enjoy each other’s company, and bask in the beauty of the city. Making it an ideal choice for a memorable and romantic date night.

We recently enjoyed a Circle Line cruise, sailing along the Hudson River and right around to Brooklyn. We had the New York CITYPass which allowed us to do this cruise and four other New York activities!

Hopefully you’ll find something suitable in this list of date ideas in New York for your date day or night in New York City. And if you have any more date ideas in New York suggestions that I may have missed – feel free to add to the comments below!

RELATED Date Ideas in New York blog posts to read:

If you’re planning a trip to New York City and need some date ideas in New York, make sure to check out my 140+ page travel guide eBook which you can download here to help you plan!

By Orlagh Shanks

Orlagh Shanks is the Editor of Orlagh Claire, an award-winning travel and lifestyle blog.
After working in the PR & Influencer Marketing industry, Orlagh quit her job to travel Asia for 12 months and moved to Sydney, Australia where she is now a full-time travel blogger and content creator sharing travel tips and recommendations for all 30 of the countries she’s visited so far.

0 Shares

This blog post is all about date ideas in New York.